A majority of women feel more comfortable with average to smaller-endowed penises. According to a handful of women I've spoken with. I'm Bisexual and my preference is for smaller as well, but if he's hung, I'll work with what he's got.
For those of you here whose "sexual experience" comes from porn or forum threads...the average penis length is about 12 - 14 centimeters. This is an average cock. You would have to have a micropenis (Google it) inside you not to feel anything. And for those women who crave "big cocks" to feel anything: exercise, you are probably not tight enough. For me, there is nothing more boring than a really big cock. I am small and I want ALL OF IT inside me, want to hear the "snack" when he Rams me. And I want to be able to suck the cock properly.